Contact Center Industry News

TMCNet:  Senate passes anti-photo bill

[February 26, 2013]

Senate passes anti-photo bill

Feb 26, 2013 (South Bend Tribune - McClatchy-Tribune Information Services via COMTEX) -- One of the most controversial bills in this year's General Assembly session so far -- Senate Bill 373, which would make it a crime to take photos on rural or industrial property -- passed this afternoon, sending the issue to the state House.

Sen. Travis Holdman, R-Markle, the author of the bill, referred to the strong criticism of the bill himself before the vote on the Senate floor.

Animal-rights groups and others have decried the bill as inhibiting "whistle-blowing" potential, such as animal cruelty and workplace injustices. They say other laws, including those that describe trespassing and libel, address illegal acts in which a business owner's reputation might be harmed.

"I've had many people say this is a First Amendment issue, but I believe it is a personal property rights issue," Holdman said.

He described a scenario in which someone would hire him as a plumber, and the homeowner leaves.

"While you're gone I get out my iPhone and I start videotaping and photographing things I see going on in your house," he said. "I might go into your nightstand. ... I might take a picture of your kitchen sink if you've left dishes undone a number of days ... and then I post that on the Internet." Holdman said that based on objections during committee testimony, the bill underwent several revisions, such as exempting authorities or good-faith whistle-blowers who take their evidence to an agency or law enforcement officer within 48 hours.

"We have law enforcement and we have regulatory agencies. We don't need folks taking the law into their own hands," he said. "We don't need a vigilante group with cameras and video cameras taking pictures of things that we just don't like." But Sen. Karen Tallian, D-Portage, was just as impassioned against the bill.

"This bill was originally offered as help for a few innocent farmers who are being harassed. But I think this argument isn't just about farmers," she said. "I think this bill seriously jeopardizes the free press.

"This bill puts a criminal penalty on the truth," she said. "I understand there's a need to maintain privacy. But again, we're smashing a fly with a sledgehammer. This legislation just goes too far." She and other senators also criticized the bill's 48-hour requirement.

Sen. Carlin Yoder, R-Goshen, who had submitted a similar bill, and Sen. Joe Zakas, R-Granger, voted in favor of the measure. Sen. John Broden, D-South Bend, voted against it.

It heads to a House committee for approval.

Contact Virginia Black: 574-235-6321 ___ (c)2013 the South Bend Tribune (South Bend, Ind.) Visit the South Bend Tribune (South Bend, Ind.) at Distributed by MCT Information Services

[ Back To Cloud Contact Center's Homepage ]


Featured Resources

Featured Report
Millennial Research on Customer Service Expectations

Millennial Research on Customer Service Expectations

The "why" behind this research is simple: our clients recognize that different generations bring different expectations, varied communication preferences and new customer service patterns to the customer experience...
Featured Report
Optimizing the Customer Experience through Cloud Contact Centers

Optimizing the Customer Experience through Cloud Contact Centers

Adoption of cloud contact centers is on the rise. Findings from Aberdeen's January 2014 'Public Cloud vs. On-Premise: How to More Effectively Deploy a Cloud Center' study shows that 31% of contact centers are deployed in the cloud, and our related blog post highlights that companies anticipate their adoption of cloud technology to rise further throughout 2014...
Featured Report
Aberdeen report

Aberdeen Report: Cloud for Mid-Sized Contact Centers – What You Must Know

Cloud Technology is opening new doors for many businesses. However, it does so only when it's combined with the use of best practices and key technology enablers. This document highlights the adoption of cloud technology by mid-size contact centers and illustrates the reasons driving their investments...
Featured Whitepaper
Aberdeen report

Seven Critical Capabilities to Demand From Your Cloud Contact Center Provider

To deliver a world-class customer experience, your contact center must be flexible and reliable, while providing all the tools agents and supervisors need to manage their workflows. Here are seven critical capabilities to look for when deploying a contact center in the cloud...
Featured Webinar

Contact Center Economics and the Cloud

Together, Bob and Drew will help you understand the economic value of upgrading technology, important business and financial considerations, and how to compare total cost of ownership of a premises vs. cloud or hosted solution. Watch the webinar on-demand now...
Featured Datasheet
Zipwire Cloud Contact Center

Zipwire Cloud Contact Center

The appeal of moving services to the cloud is obvious. Cloud services offer reliability and robust feature sets without the need to implement or maintain complex contact center infrastructure. The Zipwire™ cloud-based contact center allows businesses to leverage the flexibility and cost savings of cloud architecture while offering a seamless, first-class customer experience...